Live Blog: Student Walkout and Sit-In
UPDATE: 9:15 a.m. - Public Safety deems the bomb and firearm threat 'not credible.' To wrap up, here is a photo-essay summarizing the past 33 hours' events. [gallery size="large" ids="17148,17538,17539,17512,17513,17514,17515,17516,17517,17518,17519,17520,17521,17522,17523,17525,17526,17527,17528,17529,17530,17531,17532,17534,17535,17536,17537"] 10:51 pm - Update - So what does the signed document actually say?An amended document was signed this evening by President Eisgruber, Vice President Calhoun, and Dean Dolan.Demand 1- Concerning Woodrow WilsonPresident Eisgruber will write to the Head* of Wilson College about removing the mural of Woodrow Wilson. It's ultimately up to Professor Cadava, but Eisgruber will say his personal opinion (that it should be removed).As for Woodrow Wilson's name throughout the rest of the University, President Eisgruber promises to email Katie Hall, the chair of the Board of Trustees, to start discussions with the Black Justice League (BJL) about Wilson's legacy on campus. President Eisgruber also promises toward greater ethnic diversity of memorialized artwork on campus.Demand 2 - Creation of black space and affinity housing Four rooms in the Carl A. Fields Center will be immediately assigned for Cultural Affinity Groups. The BJL will be involved in a group working towards creating Affinity Housing.Demand 3- Cultural Competency Training and the Diversity Gen Ed Requirement.Work with Exec Director John Kolligian to increase cultural competency training for CPS staff. The admins promise that the BJL will be involved further discussions about cultural competency training with the General Education Task Force (invitation for BJL to attend meeting on Dec 8), the FACP (Faculty Advisory Committee on Policy), and with Dean Prentice, Dean of the Faculty.Demand 4 - No formal discipline will be issued if students leave peacefully.In the future, information about discipline and protest will be clearly presented.Finally, accountability. Dean Gonzalez is the "point person" for checking up that all these things are happening. The Inclusion at Princeton website should be regularly updated by the Vice Provost of Diversity and Inclusion.And that's a wrap, folks.9:05 pm - As sit-in concludes, bomb and firearm threat goes out across campusAs students are celebrating inside Nassau Hall, the Department of Public Safety issues a warning about a bomb and firearm threat that they received via email "that made reference to a student protest on campus." The threat was non-specific.
“That’s the only information we’ve received and we’re doing exactly what we said in the alert. We’ve stepped up patrols, and we’re contacting other local law enforcement agencies and they’re assisting us in the investigation," Duncan Harrison, Associate Director of Support Services at Public Safety, said. "We’re tracking email to see where it came from. At this point, we don’t have much more than that."
No one is being evacuated due to the non-specific nature of the threat.
8:45 pm - Students begin to exit Nassau Hall for the first time in ~33 hours.
8:40 pm-Students are signing the document before they leave. Here is the text of the document.8:20 pm - BREAKING: Eisgruber, Dolan and Calhoun signed the document. Students are about to leave through the front entrance.8:15 pm - BREAKING: Eisgruber, Dolan and Calhoun have agreed to sign the most recent version of the document. They are about to sign now.7:50pm - Negotiations inside have ground to a stalemate; Cornel West calls again. The BJL has asked President Eisgruber to send an email request to the head of Board of Trustees to begin discussion over the removal of the name of Woodrow Wilson from the school. Eisgruber wanted to make change the wording to "make a decision on the name" and not "make a decision on the removal of the name."Currently, the document says, "the board of trustees will collect information on the campus community's opinion on Woodrow Wilson School name and then make a decision regarding the removal of the name."Eisgruber says he will only sign if the wording is changed to "on the name."Meanwhile, West congratulated the protest leaders over a phone call.7:15 pm-stalemate inside, singing and chanting in the atrium.Words from the protest reverberate in the atrium. "We're here. We've been here. We ain't leaving. We are loved."Yaw Owusu-Boahen reads a text message from inside the President's office that says the protesters and the administration have not come to a consensus.He starts a chant: "No justice, no peace." And leaves to get his things to spend the night in the atrium.
6:23 pm-students are still debating whether to accept all the proposed changes.6:09 pm-Students have agreed to all of the changes. Preparing to reprint and sign document with Eisgruber and administration. Meeting set with Board of Trustees members in Prospect House at 6:30.6:00 pm-Students are debating whether to accept or reject Eisgruber's requested changes to the document. 5:52 pm-Eisgruber and students are fighting over his requested changes to the document of demands. "We know that you are a constitutional lawyer and we know that you want to make this as vague as possible," student says."That is not true, I want to be as precise as possible," Eisgruber responds.5:46 pm-Internet issues resolved, Eisgruber, Calhoun, and Dolan are reviewing document:
5:33 pm-Students are printing out document for president Eisgruber to review and possibly sign.In possibly the least surprising thing to happen all day, issues with the printer are delaying this (possibly) historic moment.Eisgruber is all over trying to solve these printer issues. "We are having email problem," he bemoans to group of students.The man in action (we know the picture is not vertical):
5:15 pm-BJL leaders summarize the meeting in order to ask for administrators to sign document with demands they believe have been agreed upon.Eisgruber is hesitant to print out document.
Demands agreed upon by administration with students members of the Black Justice League, all language paraphrased:
- Eisgruber will write to Wilson College head Professor Cadava about the Woodrow Wilson mural in the Wilson dining hall, with personal recommendation to remove mural.
- Eisgruber will write to the Board of Trustees with regards to beginning conversation about changing the name of the Woodrow Wilson School
- Board of Trustees will collect opinions of community on name change
- Agreeing to identify the four rooms in the Carl A. Fields Center that will be specifically designated for minority groups.
- Black Justice League will be involved in a working group on affinity housing that will be staffed by the residential college heads.
- Enhancing the cultural competency training, working with Executive Director of CPS John Kolligian
- President Eisgruber will make introduction between Black Justice League and Dean of Faculty Deborah Prentice to further discuss cultural competency training.
- Concerning amnesty for those who remained in President Eisgruber’s office, there will be no formal disciplinary action for those who leave this room tonight.
- Jill Dolan: "What about the gen ed requirement?" Dean Gonzalez will discuss with General Education Task Force the possibility of adding a diversity requirement.
Students ask for someone to remain in contact with to ensure that they feel that the issues are being adequately addressed. Dean Khristina Gonzalez has been designated as the point person.5:11 pm- complex back and forth taking place over the intricacies of the Princeton bureaucracy. Will update when any of this makes any sense. Lots of acronyms being thrown around in here... 5:05 pm--Students ask Eisgruber: "What can you do?""I need the community behind me to do what I do," Eisgruber responds."One of the things that I can do is set priorities for my own administration and diversity and inclusion are some of those priorities."5:00 pm-Leaders debate with Eisgruber, Dolan, and Calhoun about the ability to create institutional change
“Institutions are so elaborate and slow to change,” Dolan says, arguing that it will be a long process.
"That sounds like an excuse," student responds. "I haven’t heard much personal accountability and personal responsibility to take concrete steps to create this change."
Dean Dolan: "What I was trying to say about incremental change, which I know is not a phrase that sits well with you all, is that over these years I have seen people having these conversations and little by little things have change. That's how change happens in institutions like this."
4:50 pm-report from outside Eisgruber's office that students will gather outside Nassau Hall at 5:00 pm.
Meanwhile, inside Eisgruber reiterates his inability to demand for faculty to attend cultural competency training."I don’t have the authority, Dean Dolan doesn't have the authority, to impose this [mandatory training]," Eisgruber says.Current debate is circling in on demand by student leaders for Eisgruber and other leading faculty state their support for mandatory training, even if they cannot, themselves, mandate the training."Faculty governance is an important principle of the university," Eisgruber says. "I also believe in the importance of faculty self-governance."4:45 pm-"No formal disciplinary action has begun, nor will it begin, if you leave the building," Vice President Calhoun says. "I am willing to say that any action that would move towards a disciplinary action would require someone taking all your names," Calhoun said. "That did not happen, that will not happen when you leave this building."Important to note the role that press and support from significant figures like Cornel West for student protesters may have played in the University's decision to not begin a disciplinary process.4:41 pm- The final demand. A request for no disciplinary action. "This protest was important because we were trying to make Princeton a more inclusive space," Asanni York says."We are demanding amnesty," Wilgory Tanjong says."This is routine," Calhoun says. "I don't want you to think that this was unique or particular to this event."4:36 pm-ongoing discussion of diversity of faculty.“Please don't think that this is the first time we’ve been appalled by those numbers” Dolan says of the tiny percentage of Black faculty at University.Eisgruber: "It is not a coincidence that the Dean of the Faculty is the person who coauthored the report on the importance of diversity in our faculty."4:28 pm-Students demand a diversity requirement for undergraduate studentsDemand is for a class on marginalized communities or the history of marginalized groups. Students also demand that there should be extra scrutiny to make sure that these classes truly and thoroughly cover the topic instead of paying lip-service to the subject.Dean Dolan says that the General Education Task Force is already considering adopting a diversity requirement. The issue is on the agenda for the Task Force's meeting on December 8th. Dolan says that they are willing to have members of Black Justice League speak at that meeting.4:23 pm-Continued conversation over cultural competency training"You're all talking about love, this is the language you all talk in. I think it's very hard to put that language into a mandatory context," Dolan says."I would also add that the fact that faculty have to vote to take on this matter themselves, also speaks to the need to hire faculty that would do that," student says, "that means hiring more Black faculty.""The hardest thing that we can do is have the faculty vote on mandatory training for themselves, that's like asking them to tax themselves," Eisgruber says.4:02 pm--Demand for cultural competency trainingBJL wants to have students involved in the creation of a cultural competency training for staff, faculty, and students."We think it is just so important for there to be an integration of learning about marginalized people," Esther Maddox says. "We think it's important that specifically Black students feel comfortable interacting with students in this environment."Eisgruber: "I think it's extraordinarily important for our students to feel comfortable interacting with our faculty and I think it's important for our faculty to feel comfortable interacting with all students."“I think it would be very useful for members of the Black Justice League to meet with the Dean of the Faculty [Deborah Prentice],”Eisgruber says. “She tells me that mandatory trainings are not a particularly effective way to do this, but she thinks that there are effective ways to do this.”Administration has pushed back strongly against the idea of mandatory training. Calhoun argues that people change their behavior when they feel they were forced to do something.It is the people who don't want to go to cultural competency training who need to go to the training the most, one student argues."The best way to do this is to change the culture about what it means to be trained," student says.UPDATED:"The only way we can get a mandatory training for the faculty is to have the faculty vote to put this into practice and that is very hard to do," Eisgruber says. "We have had some discussions about how we can go about it [creating faculty training] but this is something we can do better." 3:50 pm-"President Eisgruber, I just want you to understand that we are here because Black students are not treated fairly on this campus," student leader Wilgory Tanjong says to President Eisgruber.“You're very much a part of this campus and this community. You are very important for this campus and this community,” Eisgruber responds, acknowledging the unique challenges that Black students face at Princeton."You can't admit to the fact that Black students on this campus are treated unfairly and say that you just want to treat everyone equally," Tanjong says. "Because other voices have to be prioritized over others because historically those voices have been so marginalized and muted."3:42 pm-Students raise demand for affinity housing for people interested in Black culture.The housing would be similar to the Edwards Arts Collective. Students would live in a specific hall or section, designated specifically for this dorm space.Dean Dolan says that "it is part of the conversation we are having now" but warns that it is a very complicated process to find dorm space for affinity housing. Explains the long bureaucratic process it would entail to make these housing changes.Students add that they want a designated space for Black students on campus as the University works through the process of creating affinity housing.Dean Calhoun says that creating such a space is viable immediately inside the Carl A. Fields Center.Dolan acknowledges student frustrations with moving through the University bureaucratic processes. "I know you're tired," Dolan says. Offers the Black Justice League a seat at the table at next meeting over residential college housing, although vague on further details."I honestly can't be that specific because we are at the beginning of even figuring out what that process would be,” Dolan says in what is a less-than-thrilling response.Students demand that they have a seat at the table for every part of the discussion over affinity housing.3:40 pm-Eisgruber says that there is no different process for changing the name of Stanhope Hall, the home of the African American Studies Department, which is named after a racist benefactor of the University. 3:36 pm-Eisgruber on legacy of Woodrow Wilson"Im happy to work with people to produce a sufficiently complicated portrait of who Woodrow Wilson was.""Woodrow Wilson was a racist he was also someone who suppressed speech with anti-sedition laws.""I think as a University it is our job to bring out the complexity of who he was."Eisgruber promises to write to Dean of Wilson School to encourage the creation of some type of plaque or note to acknowledge Wilson's racist past. Says he also believes the University should work with the University archivist to help explore in more detail that past.3:31 pm-Eisgruber agrees that mural of Woodrow Wilson in Wu-Wilcox dining hall should be removed“Im happy to write to professor Cadava to take up this issue and, not only that, but to remove that mural,”Eisgruber says. “I just don't think it’s the right place for a mural of that kind.”“I will convey that to professor Cadava tonight,” Eisgruber adds.“The one thing, Destiny, where I can’t make promises is that I don't have strong views about what goes on that wall in Wilson College but I do feel that it should be meaningful for the people in Wilson College," Eisgruber says. "I agree entirely that we should have a far more diverse set of images on this campus. It would be much more meaningful to me, personally."3:30 pm-Students list their demands. First up, renaming the Woodrow Wilson School. "we know that change doesn't happen overnight," Destiny Crockett says, asking for the Board of Trustees to take up the issue of renaming buildings on this school.Eisgruber says that the head of the Board of Trustees, Kathryn Hall, is interested in beginning a committee on the board to begin a process to think about changing the name of the Woodrow Wilson School."I am confident that the board will put together a process on which to collect views and information on this question," Eisgruber says.3:25 pm-Before speaking, students show Eisgruber a video made by allies earlier today in Nassau Hall atrium:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6e7FlS8q6F0&app=desktop3:21 pm-Eisgruber arrives in the office to meet with student leaders:3:00 pm-protest leaders are waiting inside the president's office for the president to arrive. He will be accompanied by Dean Jill Dolan and Vice President Calhoun.
2:08 pm--the University has agreed to allow the other leaders of the Black Justice League who were outside of Eisgruber's office to enter the office for a strategy session. The leaders outside, however, are not allowed to remain when Eisgruber comes to speak with the sit-in organizers who have remained inside through the night. The Press Club is no longer inside the office as the students strategize in private, but will be returning to cover their meeting with Eisgruber shortly.Updates, of course, to come.s:02 pm- Cornel West voices support for student protesters to his 597,000 followers on Facebook. Calls for amnesty for students engaged in the sit-in:
Link to the change.org petition can be viewed here.2:00 pm-The student leaders are staying firm in their decision to remain in the president's office, although that means they will not be joined by their peers outside. 1:55 pm-- President Eisgruber has agreed to come meet with the student protesters currently in his office. However, the administration has issued an ultimatum:They can either meet with Eisgruber and trustees in his office without the leaders of the protest who are outside of his office, or they can agree to leave his office for good and hold the meeting in a conference room in Nassau Hall with the other student protesters allowed entrance.1:30 pm--Notes from the office of the presidentNo updates yet on whether or when Eisgruber will be releasing a statement, although rumors have been spreading about a possible upcoming statement from "Nassau Hall." Of course, Nassau Hall itself is currently occupied by the student protesters, who have been here now for over 24 hours.In other news, being in Eisgruber's office has led those in here to uncover new things the inner workings of Princeton's president. Chief among them was the discovery that Eisgruber alphabetizes all the books in his office, of which there are many.Photographic proof here (a selection of L to M):
12:23 pm- Update on EisgruberThe university president was just spotted walking through the gates on Nassau Street towards a side entrance of Nassau Hall. He has been rumored to be releasing a public statement soon on the current situation on campus. He has still not shown up in his office.12:15 pm - Where is President Eisgruber? President Eisgruber has not made an appearance at his office so far today, where 20 students are still conducting their sit-in. He was seen entering Nassau Hall earlier this morning, around 8:30am, through a side-door, and may have left the building mid-morning. The administration is not providing details as to where he might be.11:45 am-Thoughts from inside president's officeThe mood inside Nassau Hall is strange.It's important to remember that students inside Eisgruber's office remain threatened with disciplinary action. Yet, all the while, University administrators--from the deans in the Office of the Dean of Undergraduate Students (ODUS) to student life deans within the residential colleges--have been constantly present since 5:00 pm yesterday, when students were officially considered in violation of University rules, providing support and facilitating discussion with the students in here.11:30 am-Black alumnus and attorney Rhinold Palmer visits protestors inside Eisgruber's office. "I've been in here twice," he jokes, speaking of student sit-in in 1978.Tells students to think about how to "institutionalize" their alumni connections, like the eating clubs have done.11:00 am-Students in the atrium make posters explaining what the sit-in means to them. They're going to share photos and videos on social media."We want to keep control of the narrative and broaden our support," said Joanna Anyanwu '15, now a grad student in the Woodrow Wilson School who is helping lead protest in the atrium. "A lot of the misinformation that is being spread by detractors is taking away from that support."She said some students think that the protest is the work of an isolated group. She also said that activists have been talking to administrators about these goals for more than a year.
10:25 am-Student town hall in atrium of Nassau Hall.Student protest leaders are facilitating a town hall discussion in the atrium outside of the president's office suite. Students are sharing personal stories and their thoughts in small groups.At the beginning of the meeting, students turned to the person next to them and said, "thank you for being here."9:53 am-Dr. Cornel West addresses students in Eisgruber's office on speakerphone."Y'all making a statement, aren't you," Dr. West says."How can I be of support?" he asks.Students participating in sit-in ask West if he can help lead the way in drafting a letter for prominent professors across the country to sign in support of the protests in Nassau Hall."We're going to get Sister Toni involved,"West says, speaking of Nobel Laureate and University professor emeritus Toni Morrison.9:45 am-Students sitting in the atrium of Nassau Hall.Students inside Eisgruber's office are discussing their plans for the day and their demands for the trustees and the administration.
9:00 am-The Trustees of the University are arriving on campus today for one of their yearly meetings. With the sit-in now underway, a source in the administration says there is a possibility that some trustees will be coming to Eisgruber's office today to meet with the students still inside. 8:35 am-Doors of Nassau Hall open. Students enter into public atrium. The door to the office suites, where Eisgruber's office is located, is shut. Students cannot enter into that area.
Photo credit: Mary Hui8:20 am-President Eisgruber enters Nassau HallEisgruber was seen entering the building through a side entrance. Students inside have yet to see him. Updates to come.7:30 am, Day #2- Good morning from inside Nassau Hall.
Here's what you need to know as the protests go into their second day:
Led by the Black Justice League, a few hundred Princeton students participated in an organized walkout from class at 11:30 am yesterday. After holding a brief rally on the steps of Nassau Hall, the students made their way into Nassau Hall and began their sit-in in President Chris Eisgruber's office, stating that they would not leave until the president had agreed to sign their document of demands.
Those demands include the renaming of all buildings and institutions associated with Woodrow Wilson, the creation of space for Black students on campus, mandatory cultural training for faculty, and the inclusion of an African American Studies course to the University's distribution requirements.
Early in the afternoon, President Eisgruber met and spoke with the protestors in his office, at that time numbering a couple dozen with many more student supporters in the atrium outside.
By 5pm, the number of students still in Nassau hall had thinned out slightly when Princeton University's Dean of Students Kathleen Deignan came to warn students that, if the students stayed overnight, they could face possible disciplinary consequences from the University's judicial committee for having occupied a private space while the building was officially closed.
Initially, the students had planned to stay in Nassau Hall until 5 pm and then return the following morning at 9am to continue their protest. Those plans were altered by updates from Dean Deignan as well as the director of Public Safety, Paul Ominsky, who explained that once students left Eisgruber's office, they would not be allowed to return.
Those who remained inside Eisgruber's office decided to spend the night, ultimately leaving over a dozen students to spread their sleeping bags across the spacious office of the president.
Before going to sleep, the students in Eisgruber's office were visited by a slew of high-profile figures. Professor Eddie Glaude, the chair of the African American Studies Department, came to speak with the students. He was followed later by Reverend William Barber, a famous civil rights activist from North Carolina, who led the students in the office in prayer. Afterwards, Ruth Simmons, the first Black provost of Princeton University in the 1990s who went on to become the first Black president of an ivy league university at Brown, came in to speak with the students about their goals.
At the same time, students, locked out of Nassau Hall, began to gather outside. After marching through campus, a group of around 100 students set up camp on the steps of Nassau Hall,with around 50 staying the night, camping outside the building in solidarity with their peers inside.
What's next:
At 9 am, the students outside will be holding a town hall in the atrium of Nassau Hall.
Outside Nassau Hall, the 50 or so students who camped out last night woke up as the sky got light to get ready for Day Two. People had slept on the footsteps of Nassau Hall, in tents pitched on the front lawn, and in sleeping bags under trees.
As for the students inside Nassau Hall, How long they will stay here is anyone's guess. Those inside have sleeping bags and plenty of water and food. But they also might need to go to class. As one of the student leaders of the protest said last night, "the revolution cannot be compromised, but I gotta graduate."
-GSF
[gallery columns="2" ids="17384,17385,17386,17387"]2:55 am-Lights out in Nassau HallStudents tuck themselves in to their sleeping bags on the floor of president Eisgruber's office. Preparing for a long day ahead. Alarm set for 7:30 AM.Until then, GSF signing off.
12:00 am -
This photo was taken earlier this evening, when a group of approximately 100 students stood on the grass outside the windows of President Eisgruber's office, where about 40 students remained camped out in their sit-in against racial injustice at the university. The students outside chanted lines like "No justice, no peace," and "We will not be disciplined, we will be loved," in support of those inside.
11:30 pm-New York Times publishes article on sit-in.
The sit-in at Princeton has reached the pages of the paper of record, with a byline by Press Clubber Ally Markovich.
11:00 pm-food break.
Students outside of Nassau Hall are enjoying cookies and other refreshments as they continue their protest.
10:35 pm-Simmons exits Eisgruber's office
"You be careful, take care of yourselves!" Simmons says before she departs.10:35 pm-Students are pitching tents outside of Nassau Hall
10:30 pm, inside Eisgruber's office-Simmons discusses students' fear of disciplinary action.
"You're not really doing anything that is strange yet," she says. "Protest on college campus is a high art."
"You have not abridged anyone’s rights, except the President’s of being in this office," she says.
On a lighter note, she adds a story about her time at Brown:
"You know this is very scary for me because I was a President!" she says. She says that students never tried to sit-in her office, except once: "when I was out of town, students came to my office naked," she says. "So you're on higher ground!"
10:25 pm-Students getting ready for a long night ahead on the doorstep of Nassau Hall.
10:20 pm-Ruth Simmons speaks of her experience as the president of Brown University and a Trustee of Princeton.“I’m probably an older generation and I worry less about what people say and more about what people do," she says. “You have to work towards the doing.”Simmons tells story of beginning to sob while trying to explain the experience of Black students to the trustees of Princeton University:“It’s hard to explain to people what it’s like to be in this kind of environment and feel the weight of the history around you,” Simmons says of being a Black student or faculty member at ivy league universities.“That's what people need to understand. Just how deep and pervasive and painful this is.”Simmons was a faculty member at Princeton (and later Provost) from 1983 until 1995.“It was rough in those days," she says. "It was really rough in those days.”10:00 pm- Reverend Barber addresses students outside of Nassau Hall
Reverend William Barber, after speaking with students inside Eisgruber’s office, provided words of encouragement to approximately 150 students gathered outside Nassau Hall.
“It is your space. Hold your space,” Barber said. “If they’re going to have to prosecute all of you then let them make their case”
“Don’t leave your friends alone. Make sure America has to see all of this diversity,” Reverend Barber said. “Dealing with race and class has to involve all of us.”
He repeatedly emphasized: “It is your space. And you must hold your space.”
9:50 pm-Ruth Simmons, the first Black Provost of Princeton University and the first Black president of an Ivy League university enters room as Reverend Barber exits. Simmons is also a trustee of the University."How are things going," she asks."Do you mean on campus?" student asks."I mean in here!" Simmons responds.Simmons asks students, "so, what's your plan?""The movement is definitely continuing," student leader responds.Simmons on the importance of the legacy of Woodrow Wilson:
“Why do we even care about Woodrow Wilson at this juncture? The reason that we care is because we believe that his legacy is sticking to these walls. Because a lot of time you are walking around this campus and you feel like you don't matter...the reason is because his legacy is sticking around these walls.”
Simmons asks students: "If you ask yourself what would be meaningful to do, that would things change for all time, that would be interesting!" 9:40 pm-Reverend William Barber, leader of the Moral Mondays movement in North Carolina, comes back inside to speak with students in Eisgruber's office. He was here speaking in the Chapel earlier today."Y'all are serious, aren't you?" he says. Advises students to read up on history of student protests."Tell your own story," Reverend Barber says. Encourages students to give testimonies of why they are here."I have to fly back tonight but you students are making me want to stay," he says. "You know I love a good fight."Reverend Barber leads the students in prayer, as they all hold hands together."Most of all God, give them strength that they are not going to let anybody turn them around," Barber ends prayer.
9:13 pm-Students outside of Whitman College, with sleeping bags. Across campus, students are preparing to spend the night outside of Nassau Hall.It's going to be a long night.
9:10 pm-Protesters march through Wilson College. Part of the demands by student protesters is the renaming of Wilson College as well as all other buildings and institutions bearing Woodrow Wilson's name. https://twitter.com/UnivPressClub/status/6671619311412224009:05 pm- Meanwhile, on Yik Yak:[gallery columns="2" size="medium" link="file" ids="17279,17285"]
8:58 PM-Protesters marching through Frist, chanting "no justice, no peace" as students eat late meal.https://twitter.com/UnivPressClub/status/6671594470647234578:50 pm-students outside Nassau Hall are marching towards Frist. They will then head back up campus towards Rocky.8:35 pm- students are chanting and singing outside of Nassau Hallhttps://twitter.com/UnivPressClub/status/667153608425742336https://twitter.com/UnivPressClub/status/6671547887910051848:30 pm-Dean Calhoun speaks to students as protesters continue chanting outside."I don't want you to feel that you have to tell your story over and over again for the university to take action," Dean Calhoun says. "But I hear that that's what's been happening.""We have work to do. We have serious work to do," she says. "Today, tomorrow and the day after."
As she speaks, chants from protestors outside reverberate in the office: "We are proud to be on the side of justice."
8:20 pm- In the office space outside of President Eisgruber's office, administrators, including the Dean of Students and the Executive Director of Public Safety as students continue to discuss with Dean Calhoun. "We want to leave this university in a better state than we came in," one student explains to Dean Calhoun."I'm tired of being at this university, sometimes I wake up and I don't want to go to class. I'm tired of hearing from people that the grades I get here and the place I am in here wasn't earned." 8:12 pm- W. Rochelle Calhoun, vice-president of student life, is speaking to students inside Eisgruber's office currently. 7:45 pm-Outside Nassau Hall, students continue to protest. A permit has been obtained from the University to allow students to camp out on the steps of Nassau Hall for the night. Students inside are still deliberating whether they will spend the night.7:30 pm - students chant outside Nassa Hall: "We're here. We've been here. We ain't leaving. We're loved." They also chant: "It is our duty to fight for our freedom. It is our duty to win. We must must love each other and support each other. We have nothing lose to but our chains." 7:15 pm - Students outside sing "We shall overcome" and "Amazing Grace." They chant, "We won't tolerate hate." 7 pm - Chanting outside Nassau Hall. ~100 students. 6:50-Professor Eddie Glaude, chair of the African American Studies Department, enters Eisgruber's office to address students.“I just came over to talk,” Glaude said. "You started the action and there are some consequences that you are immediately confronting," adding that "the question is whether at this stage in the game you are ready to face the consequences. This is a long distance race not a sprint."6:10-students are questioning whether Public Safety Director was telling the truth about whether students will be allowed back in Nassau Hall tomorrow. 6:08-order of pastries arrives in the name of a Princeton community member, who is apparently currently out of the country. The pastries have assumedly been ordered as an act of solidarity and support for students. 6:07-Ominsky clarifies statement on whether students will be allowed, after being pressed by students. "The atrium will be open tomorrow for all students," Ominksy says.6:04--Director of Public Safety speaks with students in Eisgruber's office."As far as I know the building will be open tomorrow," Paul Ominsky, the Executive Director says.Students ask him to say that the building will be open specifically for students."Can you say that these students right here will be allowed back in tomorrow?" student asks."I can't say that," he says."I'm trying to help," Ominsky says.5:45 pm - students are still deciding whether to stay.No one is being kicked out of Nassau Hall. The Administration has warned that students who stay in Nassau Hall, specifically in President Eisgruber's office, may face disciplinary consequences for staying.5:25 pm - students are deciding whether to stay in the office overnight.About 40 students are in President Eisgruber's office now, weighing whether its worth potential disciplinary consequences to stay in the building overnight.One student leader read aloud a passage from Malcolm X's "Message to the Grassroots."Another said: "our first priority here is graduating.""I'm not trying to sit anywhere except this room," one student leader said.The students are currently speaking with a Princeton alumnus who led a sit-in in 1978 to pressure Princeton to divest from South Africa.5:15 pm - University Administration warns of disciplinary consequences for students who stay in the building past 5:00Kathleen Deignan, the Dean of Students, tells students in Eisgruber's office that they can expect possibly consequences if they remain in the building."You should anticipate that there could be disciplinary consequences when students occupy private space," Deignan said."The judicial committee is not likely to analyze a case or try to predetermine what the consequences would be before they hear all of the information.""No one can remain in the building after the building closes," she said."If you do not leave, then the University will have ODUS staff and Public Safety staff here in the building, but that does not mean that you will not be in violation of University regulations," she says (emphasis added). 4:03 pm: At least 5 protesters are planning to stay in the office after the building closes at 5:30 pm tonight.They are concerned that if they leave, they would be unable to come back to the office in the morning, according to Esther Maddox, one of the organizers of the protest."The idea is that we'd stay, and let people in in the morning," she said. She brought a blanket and a pillow. Some other protesters brought sleeping bags.3:25 pm: An AP Photographer is kicked out of Eisgruber's office by University spokesman Martin Mbugua. He told the photographer that no outside media is allowed in the office."They don't want this to go national," Asanni York, one of the organizers of the protest, said.3:16 pm YikYak Update: Princeton students voice support anonymously for Eisgruber. A top post right now simply says "#EisgruberMatters," a clear reference to the #BlackLivesMatter movement.[gallery ids="17214,17212,17213"]2:50 pm - Reverend William Barber, leader of the Moral Mondays movement in North Carolina, speaks to the protesters in the office.Rev. Barber said that he "just wanted to come in and feel the energy," and he tells protesters to "hold your stance." Barber said that when he heard about a protest of institutional racism, he had to come see it.He leads protests in North Carolina against the state legislature there, and he connected the two protests. He told the protesters to sing in the space and led them in a song that he sings at Moral Mondays.He's speaking in the Princeton University Chapel tonight.The last sit-in that we're aware of happened in 1995. Seventeen students sat in the office of then President Harold Shapiro, while 100 others rallied outside. According to the New York Times, the students then wanted more administrative support for Asian-American and Hispanic studies, and the establishment of a center for ethnic studies.The University President at the time, Harold Shapiro, was openly resistant to the student demands. "I am not willing to discuss these or any other issues while this inexcusable occupation of university office space continues," Shapiro said in a statement.2:00 pm- Professor Joshua Guild holds precept for HIS 387: African-American History from Reconstruction to the Present in Nassau HallGuild said that students requested that professors hold precept in Nassau Hall, and that the material discussed in the class connected to the protest.Plus, "a third of the class was already there."Earlier today-a little before protests begin, Nassau Hall announces name change for Masters of Residential Colleges. "Masters" will now be called "heads" of residential college."I enthusiastically support the change adopted by our heads of college," Eisgruber said. "The new title better describes their roles, and it does away with antiquated terminology that discomfited some students, faculty, and the heads of college themselves."1:20-doors of Nassau Hall are now closed but not locked 1:12 pm- doors of Nassau Hall are now locked. People can only get in if someone opens from inside. 1:05 pm - Student leader summarizes: Eisgruber doesn't agree with the WWS name change or with the mandatory competency training for faculty.He did agree to the black space.
"This is our black space until further notice," one student says.
1:04 pm-Eisgruber and Dolan leave the office out of a side door. Asanni blasts Kendrick Lamar's Alright from loudspeaker. The song has become a rallying cry in protests across the country. https://twitter.com/UnivPressClub/status/667040956336746496“we gon' be alright,” the chorus repeats.1:01 pm - Asanni York brings up the fact that the front doors of Nassau Hall are being locked. Professors are trying to get in, and they can't. Eisgruber responds that the office is very full and we can't have any more people. Updates about the doors to come.12:59 pm - "As an alumni of this University, you were never educated in cultural, racism topics." - Wilglory Tanjong '1812:56 pm - A student describes an experience last year where students left Eisgruber's office crying because the students felt they weren't being heard. "I'm sorry," Eis says, "I'm sorry about that."
Even as a woman on this campus, I don't see myself reflected everywhere."Chris doesn't have the power to do everything.""We've been having conversations for years, though. I'm tired of having conversations. It's time to have some wheels move." Asanni York '17.12:20 PM"You don't understand because you're white."- student"You understand how that institutionalizes racism." -student"Can we trailblaze something for once?"-student"Woodrow Wilson perpetuated an ideology that he's led to the continual genocide of black people."-student"We owe white people nothing if not for the evilness and white hatred. We would not have to be fighting for our rights in this country."-student"To idolize him, that is disgusting, because I am reminded that my people are second class citizens.""This too is my university and I am working to claim it. My people built this place. And he [Wilson] is not what we believe." - student"Woodrow Wilson can't be excused because of the times he was a part of, but he also created things at the University--like the beginnings of diversity at the University.", referring to religious diversity. - Eis"Like virtually all historical figures I know, he did things that are blameworthy and things that are honorable." -Eis"I agree that we need to be explicit and recognize the racism of Woodrow Wilson and we shouldn't venerate him--" Eis"You can still easily praise him and honor him, even if his name is still on the building. I don't understand why his name has to be on the building.""It's not enough to acknowledge his legacy. We have to make a radical change for the first part of that to be accepted."12:12 pm. President Eisgruber arrives in office."I'm glad you're being seen and heard. It's important for the community and for the nation." - Eis"I agree with you that Woodrow Wilson was a racist." -Eis"I personally support the idea of a distribution requirement." -Eis"If you agreed with it, why don't you sign it?" -studentAwkward moment ensues."The experience of black students is different from other students on campus." "I'm happy to say that we should have a distribution requirement. It's also my view that I don't and shouldn't have authority to decide. Dean Dolan is leading a faculty-committee. But there are other faculty with different opinions. And they don't shouldn't just do what I say."Eisgruber makes a distinction between his personal beliefs and what he can put into action."What we're asking for is commitment. That's different than agreement.""I do not agree that we should change the names of Wilson College or Wilson School. Human beings have good and evil in them, and Wilson is one of those human beings."-Eis12:06 pm - Protestors sit in his office, awaiting his return. "We want to make this as awkward as possible for him." 12 pm - students sit down, covering Eisgruber's office. They promise to be here indefinitely. They are passing around a sign-up sheet with shifts covering 9-5:30, Eisgruber's working hours.The protestors encourage responsibility. "We still have to graduate this place! Do your reading. Do your psets."Professors in the African American Studies Department will bring lunch for protestors, they students say. If you have a precept in African American Studies, preceptors promise to bring class here.
11:53 - Protest continues inside. "Who built this place?""We built it!" 11:48-First students make their way into Nassau Hall. One appears to be caring a sleeping bag. Protesters enter into Nassau Hall with the intention of not leaving until President Eisgruber signs the document with their demands. Eisgruber enters with them, but does not go into his office. Current whereabouts of the President are unknown (as of 12:05 p.m.)
Students make their way from the entryway to Eisgruber's office, chanting, "We here. We been here. We ain't leavin'. We are loved." 11:40--Students read out demands"We Demand the university administration publicly acknowledge the racist legacy of Woodrow WIlson and how he impacted campus policy and culture. We also demand that steps be made to rename Wilson residential college, The Woodrow Wilson School of Public Policy and International Affairs, and any other building named after him.""We demand cultural competency training for all staff and faculty.""We Demand a cultural space on campus dedicated to Black students, and that space can be within the Carl A. Fields Center but should be clearly marked."
11:35-Eisgruber walks out of Nassau Hall, stands on the side of steps, next to leaders of Walkout
11:30-Students trickle out of McCosh
The flow of students out of McCosh, the main lecture hall on campus, was underwhelming. A small group of students walked out of McCosh 50, where Peter Singer was lecturing in his famous Practical Ethics class. Fewer students left from Anthony Grafton's History of Western Civilization lecture.
Reporting by Alexandra Markovich, Spencer Parts, Kevin Cheng, Mary Hui, and Gabriel Fisher. U